Planimeter Bench

Trace a closed curve with four instruments that measure area by rolling, sliding, or counting: the polar and linear planimeters, Prytz's hatchet, and an x–y encoder. Each reading comes with its error, split into where it comes from.

How each instrument works

Polar planimeter (Amsler, 1854). A pole is pinned down. An arm of length a runs to an elbow, and an arm of length b runs to the tracer. A wheel on the tracer arm rolls only across the arm. By Green's theorem the area is A = b·w, where w is the distance the wheel rolled. If the pole sits inside the curve, the elbow goes all the way around and you add π(a² + b² − 2bc), where c is the wheel's distance from the elbow.

Linear planimeter. The elbow runs along a straight rail instead of a circle. The same Green's-theorem argument gives A = b·w exactly, with no correction term, and the curve can be as long as the rail.

Hatchet planimeter (Prytz, 1875). A rod of length L has a knife edge at one end and a point at the other. The knife can only move along the rod, like a bicycle's back wheel. Start at a point near the middle, go out to the curve, trace it, and come back. The rod has turned by an angle θ, and A ≈ L²θ. That is only approximate: the error shrinks roughly like 1/L² and depends on where you start. The knife's path is a tractrix, and the leftover rotation is holonomy, the same effect as the rolling ball.

X–Y encoder. Two wheels count steps in x and in y, and the area is the sum of x·Δy: Green's theorem done by counting. Its error is quantization: each count is ±½ step.

Where error comes from. Tremor is the hand wobbling off the line. Slip is the wheel skidding by a random percentage at each step. Reading is the resolution of the dial or vernier. Intrinsic is what the instrument does wrong even with a perfect hand: sampling for the exact instruments, and the L²θ approximation for the hatchet.

Units. The table is 25 cm × 17.5 cm with a 1 cm grid. The wheel has a 2 cm diameter, the vernier reads 1/1000 of a turn, and the dial alone reads 1/100.